Skip to main content

BOOK REVIEW: Three Battles: Critical Clashes Between Asia and Europe By M Abul Fazl Reviewed by: Afrah Jamal

Thanks to Dost Publications for the review copy

Published In Daily Times / 17 Apr 2010

The battles of Jhelum, Plassey and Dien Bien Phu are said to be key turning points in history. Of the three, two had already been lost on a political level long before they were ‘joined’; all of them have been subjected to intense scrutiny over the years. In one, a battle-hardened general and famous military strategist won a technical victory over a warrior king. In another, a trading company challenged and defeated a major Asian powerhouse. And, finally, a guerrilla style movement led by local nationalists brought down an occupying force of superior strength.

If Plassey was decisive for the company where the British gained a convincing military victory over young Sirajuddaula, the standoff between Porus and Alexander at Jhelum exposed the fatal flaws in a famed Greek strategy and the fall of Dien Bien Phu dealt a crippling blow to the French colonial ambitions.

Strength in numbers is not a decisive factor in either of these examples. M Abul Fazl’s book focuses on social and political dynamics at play that helped shape the course of these wars and analyses the implications of such forces on both the conquered and conquering forces.

It begins in the fourth century BC with Alexander who hailed from a land credited with early laws of war and a formal military organisation. The writer attributes this to unending intense fighting on the peninsula and examines the Greek juggernaut in the lead up towards the conquest of Asia where South Asian states and statelets were up in arms on the flimsiest of pretexts. Alexander’s South Asian adventure was marked by the peculiar nature of the environment where “the outsider was not viewed as a threat but a new entrant in an ongoing game of warfare”. In drawing contrasts between the two armies, he shows South Asians and Persians to be set in the ways of the battle, “as if they were divinely ordained”. The Greeks, on the other hand, relied on “training, discipline and solidarity of the infantry” (page 12). That and the tried and tested Arbela technique failed here. He challenges those historians who credit Alexander with influencing the Indian civilisation and deems trade, not Greek invasion, to be the extent of any cultural exchange.

In the Battle of Plassey, a trading company took on Bengal — a major Asian powerhouse — and its meagre forces defeated an army of 50,000. The writer does not subscribe to the theory that discipline alone gave the British an advantage on the battlefield. He concedes that superior organisation and financial resources served them in good stead when confronting the mighty states and possession of a navy gave them a tactical advantage. “The main weakness of the Indian states was in social and political sphere” and even the acquisition of French drill masters did not help as their politics were driven by “policy, power and personal ambition”. Odds were heavily stacked against Sirajuddaula, an empire was already on precarious footing and a few judicious thrusts managed to bring down the house of cards. Combined with the fact that alliances between Indian princes and Europeans were routine, it is hardly surprising that with such combustible elements present, the slender thread holding the empire together frayed completely. He rules that in the Battle of Plassey “the fighting showed the bankruptcy of South Asian society — a ruling class held masses in contempt and the masses owed no allegiance to it.”

Finally, the narrative enters the 20th century where the “curtain fell on the Asian colonial drama” and the French forces capitulated to Viet Minh — the Vietnamese revolutionary organisation waging a guerrilla war for independence. He states that “a small country, a poor country, an overpopulated country had chosen to write the most glorious chapter in the history of 20th century de-colonisation.”

Through these essays, the writer seeks to clarify Alexander’s conquering record in the light of his Asian exploits. He explores the brittle framework supporting the Indian Empire laying emphasis on its contribution to a rising Europe and closes with a look at the gathering storm that heralded the age of neo-colonialism. He admits the historians’ version into his narrative, and expands upon their ideas to rationalise his interpretation of warfare. The military side is not the sole focus of this discussion, which struggles to define these battles by their impact on the correlation of forces. It uses the failure of Arbela as an example to bolster the view that famed Greek tactic would have been rendered useless long before the Jhelum standoff had Alexander’s opponent (Darius II) been a worthy warrior and not, as was the case, a “pathological coward”. He argues that Clive won the battle before it was engaged through bribery and not in the Napoleonic fashion (page 36). And, finally, he shows how a classic set piece battle, where the destructive power of modern warfare could have been used to successfully crush opposition, crumbled instead when faced with a new age phenomenon of nationalism (page 74). Using insight gained from other books, historians and military-men enables the writer to broaden the debate. His scholarly efforts might spark interest in academic circles.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

BOOK REVIEW: Pakistan: Beyond The ‘Crisis State’ / Author: Maleeha Lodhi

Thanks to Liberty Books for the review copy

Published in Daily Times / Saturday, June 18, 2011

Reviewed by Afrah Jamal

Published under the title: 17 Reasons to Hope

“History will be what we make it. If we go on as we are, history will have its revenge and retribution”— from the movie, ‘Good Night, & Good Luck’

A region known for most “terrorist sightings”, a place feared for harbouring medieval mindsets next to progressive thinkers and a nation shunned for having an affinity for nuclear toys. By turns a cautionary tale, an indispensable ally and an international pariah, Pakistan does not fit into any mould — for long. But its name crops up whenever things go awry.

Pakistan: Beyond the ‘Crisis State’ is a compilation of articles put together by Maleeha Lodhi that countermands the grim prognosis. When Ms Lodhi, who has served as Pakistan’s ambassador to the US and UK, acknowledges that “resilience has been part of Pakistan’s story from its inception, obscured by the single issue lens…

BOOK REVIEW: Thinner Than Skin

Published inDaily Times (Pakistan) / 23 Feb 2013
Author: Uzma Aslam Khan
Reviewed by: Afrah Jamal



Uzma Aslam Khan is the author of critically acclaimed, award winning books like Trespassing and Geometry of God. Her new novel, 'Thinner than Skin' goes off the beaten track for inspiration. A realm built upon incomprehensible layers of intrigue, violence, fairytales and legends provides the stage. People foraging for a lifeline become the props. And the inevitable soundtrack of radicalism now coursing through every fibre sets Pakistan’s modern heart to an ancient beat.

It is these paradoxes that bring its US-based protagonist, Nadir, along with a German-Pakistani girl, Farhana, on a trek from northern California to the Kaghan Valley. Wesley — the American in the background — is drawn to the mating glacier ritual, which is an actual thing. And their trusty ally/guide Irfan charts the course to their path of self-discovery past majestic mountains and ice encrusted lakes.

Their quest …

INTERVIEW: What makes a Fighter Ace? (2006)

Written many moons ago when i was an Asst. Ed with Social Pages.

Published in Defence Journal September 2006

Republished in PROBENEWS(2006)


Legend has it that a Sabre took off from Sargodha airfield to intercept Hunters on a fateful September morning & landed back with an Ace.

120 Seconds: Squadron Leader Alam in a Sabre is on Air Combat Patrol accompanied by his wingman. Upon observing IAF Hunters exiting after an unsuccessful air strike over Sargodha, Alam sets off in hot pursuit of the enemy formation. He pursues a fleeing Hunter and eventually shoots it down with a missile shot.


He spots the other members of the Hunter formations flying very low and as he approaches the trailing member he is spotted and the entire formation breaks (violent turn) in the same direction - a fatal error as in less than two minute Alam has taken out four of them, (as confirmed by more than one independent eye witness) 1 bringing his tally for the mission to five…… And an Ace is born - a legendry ins…

BOOK REVIEW: Fatal Faultlines: Pakistan, Islam and the West

Published by Daily Times / 5 May 2012

When characters in a modernised version of Sherlock Holmes make a passing reference to Karachi — they only have Daniel Pearl in mind. When the ISI agents are featured on TV shows — it is because they can stand in for the US’s favourite Cold War foes.

Such imagery goes well with the popular narrative doing the global rounds. A widening gulf between Islam and the West, the oscillating nature of the Pak-US relationship, and the alarming levels of toxicity within, is a source of concern and confusion. Now, it is the subject of a book. At the launch of Fatal Faultlines: Pakistan, Islam and the West, veteran columnist Irfan Husain briefly touched upon these incongruities. In the book, he delves deeper into a cheerless terrain where reason has been cast adrift and paranoia is king.

Fatal Faultlines: Pakistan, Islam and the West meticulously sifts through centuries of suspicion and decades of scorched earth left behind by Palestine, Iraq and Afghanistan t…

KARACHI DIARIES: 6th LADIESFUND® Women's Awards 2014

First Published in Economic Affairs (Apr 2014) P-36


They conquered Everest in their spare time & crafted empires; their names were featured in Forbes ‘30 under 30’. Somewhere along the way they had reset the bar. Their contributions had not gone un-noticed.





The people who had made the list included trailblazers, trendsetters, risk-takers & crusaders, seen at the 6th LADIESFUND® Annual Women’s Awards. An event to salute an unlikely band of heroes who left a legacy of courage & compassion also acknowledged exceptional women on the rise.


LADIESFUND® launched by Dawood Global Foundation (2007) & headed by Tara Uzra Dawood, celebrates these achievements by adding powerhouse women and their noble causes to their wall of fame. It also makes its core mission - Educate 1000 Girls, the lynchpin & encourages the entrepreneur within our ranks. The talented Alycia Dias, who performed the anthem & walked away with a musical scholarship, would be joined by other hopefuls, …

VIEW: WOMEN in the PAF: AN ENSEMBLE CAST

PUBLISHED in HILAL (Pakistan Armed Forces Magazine) Feb 2010

By Afrah Jamal

Progressive - Conservative - Contemporary - Professional; separately these terms could apply to any service; together they were reserved for just one - the PAF.

Pakistan Air Force has kept in touch with its roots through its glorious traditions and kept up with the changing times with innovative thinking. Oftentimes, traditions that made it stand apart have also stood in the way of, well - progress. Consequently, the service nimbly skipped past the one proposed change that was going to have a profound effect on the lives of countless young girls and would forever alter the way society perceived their womenfolk.

Before 1994, Lady Officers were a rare sight in the PAF. So rare in fact, that when male cadets donned wigs to represent the female species in annual variety shows, nobody wondered why. By 2010, women have become an indispensable part of the service. While, PAF was no stranger to a woman in uniform, a f…

BOOK REVIEW: Frontline Pakistan: The Struggle With Militant Islam (2007)

Author: Zahid Hussain

PUBLISHED IN THE POST JUNE 14, 2007

Reviewed by: Afrah Jamal

Frontline Pakistan: the struggle with militant Islam goes for the jugular with an insiders look at a deformed culture borne of a dated ideology, fueled by vested interest and driven by intolerance; and a nation’s complicity.

Not surprisingly, the legitimacy granted jihadists by ISI-CIA ran out soon, as did the sympathy for their jihadist actions formally perceived as heroic. Once used to counter the threat of communism, the rapid shift in their objectives that placed Pakistan’s national interest on a collision course with its security rendered them an anachronism.

This led to a parting of ways with the ISI; consequently, the deadliness of operations and depth of penetration in society seen in the context of 9/11 forever breached the line between liberators and terrorists.

Veteran journalist Zahid Hussain, Pakistani correspondent for the "Times of London", "The Wall Street Journal", …